A Christian Minister Opposes ‘God Bless America’

If you were a Christian minister who was given the opportunity to write an op-ed piece for the Washington Post, what subject would you choose? War and peace? The decline in faith among America’s young people? The increasingly empty pews in mainstream Protestant churches? The ethical decline in society? Or any of myriad other morally and religiously troubling issues?

Well, not if you were a Methodist minister named James P. Marsh, Jr.

For this man of the cloth, the issue troubling him so much that he had to write about in the Washington Post was … people standing and singing "God Bless America" at Washington National baseball games.

If you want to know how far much of mainline Christianity has declined, Pastor Marsh’s column would be a fine place to begin.

Think back to any time in American history. It is hard to imagine that a Christian minister would have any reaction to his fellow Americans standing and singing "God Bless America" other than unalloyed delight.

But that was when mainline Christian ministers believed in Christianity, sought to bring fellow Americans to God, celebrated America and hoped that God would bestow His blessings on this country.

Or to put it another way, that was before many mainstream Christians embraced another religion — leftism, the most dynamic religion of the last hundred years.

Leftism has influenced Western societies far more deeply than Christianity has since the beginning of the twentieth century. And leftism has influenced far more Christians (and Jews) than Christianity (or Judaism) has influenced leftists.

It is difficult to detect a single Christian idea or belief among the reasons the minister gives for not standing for God Bless America. All his reasons are leftist boilerplate. Had he been identified as an official of the ACLU or a professor in some social science department, no reader would have been surprised.

1. "I sit to stand for my religious beliefs."

Presumably the minister’s "religious beliefs" are Christian. But how exactly does standing to sing "God Bless America" violate Christian beliefs? He doesn’t tell us. One would think that a Christian minister would be thoroughly delighted that tens of thousands of his fellow Americans were singing "God Bless America."

2. "Being pressured to stand at a baseball game for a song that’s essentially a prayer seems, well, un-American. It feels like being pushed into the river for a baptism I didn’t choose."

Only a true-believing leftist would label people standing and singing "God Bless America" as "un-American."

3. "It’s an empty ritual, and one that I don’t think holds much theological water."

Tens of thousands of Americans of all races and backgrounds standing and singing "God Bless America" is an empty ritual? And why doesn’t asking God to bless America "hold much theological water?" What is more theologically sound than asking God to bless America (or Canada, or the UK, or Costa Rica, or Portugal or any other free country)?

4. "I’m reminded of the admonition not to pray just to be seen by others."

Who is James Marsh to judge 30,000 people’s motivations? And besides, when I stand at Los Angeles Kings hockey games when they honor a member of the armed forces, I do so in large measure precisely because I do want others, especially my son and other young people, to see me do so.

5. "When we ask for blessings to be bestowed only on ‘us,’ we are in danger of seeing ourselves as set apart from the world. "

Who but a leftist could read "God Bless America" as "God Bless only America?"

6. "Why do we all too frequently seek to invoke rituals that undermine our common bonds?"

Most of us think that this ritual strengthens our common bonds. Perhaps the pastor is unaware that the song was written by Irving Berlin, a Russian Jewish immigrant.

7. "What does the good secular humanist do during this song?"

The good secular humanist stands and sings "God Bless America." Even most liberals stand and heartily sing this song at baseball games. It takes someone who is not only left-wing but foolish to protest against doing so.

8. "We have the right to sit down when everyone else stands up."

True. And the rest of us have a right express contempt for your decision and for your using Christianity to defend it.

Dennis Prager’s latest book, "Still the Best Hope: Why the World Needs American Values to Triumph," was published April 24 by HarperCollins. He is a nationally syndicated radio show host and creator of PragerUniversity.Com.


  • Royalsfan67

    There is a guy in my fantasy baseball league who is an avowed atheist. He went out and got him self ordained a reverend. He proudly and loudly proclaims himself a reverend throughout the league and among his friends. He also performs marriage ceremonies. These people get themselves ordained so they can be seen as a religious authority when they are nothing but the opposite . Can you say Reverend Barry Lynn? How that guy got himself on all the news programs I have not a clue.
    Btw, the guy in my league? Typical leftist. We typically travel to a centralized town to conduct the draft each year. We share hotel rooms and usually stay up half the night, playing cards, having beverages, swapping stories and lies and generally having a good time. He showed up without a room. Crashed in mine, drank everyone else’s beer and never offered me or anyone else a dime for his intrusions.

  • Brian Fr Langley

    That his comments are not Biblically based is readily apparent (if you’ve ever read the Bible). What I don’t get, is why some one would claim to be a Christian leader, then apparently not refer to ( or perhaps even believe) the one document that bears witness. If the Bible is not the fount of his faith in Christ, what other fount could there possibly be????

    • Darren Perkins

      This guy he speaks of is not Christian…christian in name only does not mean a true Christian. The landscape is littered with megachurches and ministries that seek money and power and the adulation of men. When judgement time comes they will be spewed out into the lake of fire unless they repent. Far be it from me to judge individuals but I can certainly judge what is preached. They will be known by their fruit.

  • Darren Perkins

    This is why most true Christians can’t stomach going to church anymore. There is more true Christianity at an AA or Alanon meeting. At least there no one is judging you or forcing decidedly un-christian doctrine down your throat. Those 12 steps are the road to salvation. It is narrow and few there be that find it. Wide is the road that leads to destruction and many are the self-righteous that find it. They are wolves in sheeps clothing. Can you say ‘Apostate church’? That is what we have these days. Floor show, read a couple verses and out the door until next sunday. Telling us what our itching ears want to hear is their job and they do it well.