20 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Thomas P.'s avatar

No. He was yapping before midnight before Arizona closed. The idea is that some may be turned away if they hear this. Would it have made a difference? Who knows..

Expand full comment
John A. Daly's avatar

The polls closed at like 7 or 8, Thomas -- hours before the Fox team made its call.

Expand full comment
Thomas P.'s avatar

There are arguments about people still in line at the time of 7- waiting. Trying to be clairvoyant in a news room is not news - but peddling predictions is the new news. With FNC, Stirewalt was selling snow tires in Miami.

Expand full comment
John A. Daly's avatar

Thomas, Fox made the call at almost 9:30pm Arizona time, two and a half hours after Arizona polls closed. You're the one selling snow tires in Miami.

Expand full comment
Thomas P.'s avatar

I read people were in line for hours.. I donтАЩt do snow tires I stay at home.

Expand full comment
John A. Daly's avatar

For hours after the polls were closed? Come on, dude. This debate (which started with you falsely insisting the call was made while the polls were still open) has gotten beyond silly.

Expand full comment
Thomas P.'s avatar

The poles closed means people in line get to vote. Yes hours. ThatтАЩs been the complaint in Arizona for the last few election cycles

Expand full comment
John A. Daly's avatar

Lol. You said the polls weren't even closed when Fox made the call. In reality, they had been closed for 2 1/2 hours.

Most states were (and are routinely) called much sooner after the polls close, in many cases mere minutes after... when lots of people are assuredly still in line. It's done when a trailing candidate no longer has a path to victory, based on the numbers.

2 1/2 hours after the polls closed in Arizona (again, long after most races are/were called), Fox determined that Trump no longer had a path to victory in the state, based on the numbers. And they were 100% right.

The notion that a minimum of 10,500 surprise Trump supporters were still in line 2 1/2 hours after the polls closed, AND went home the moment Fox called the race, is a ridiculous, completely unsupported fantasy. But cults love fantasies, and because of that, good people like Stirewalt were treated as sacrificial lambs.

Expand full comment
Thomas P.'s avatar

How many in line is irrelevant. No one can prove or disprove it. Moreover other state voters may be influenced by this practice. When the states say all votes are in (closed), the news weenies can sell their wares. Stirewalt is not alone in his fortune telling- if he worked for CBS that night, Leslie Stahl would have kissed his rear end, and he would still be working there.

Expand full comment
John A. Daly's avatar

>>How many in line is irrelevant.

Agreed, especially 2 1/2 hours after the polls have been closed. When accurately calling a race, what's relevant is whether the trailing candidate still has a pathway to victory.

The scenario you're now entertaining (after initially falsely claiming that Fox made the call while the polls were still open) requires that there were a MINIMUM of 10,500 registered AZ voters, still in line 2 1/2 hours after the polls closed, who a) intended to vote for Trump, b) heard Fox call Arizona for Biden, and c) left the line BECAUSE they heard that call.

Let's make things very simple for you here, beginning with the most basic requirement. Please present evidence that there was anywhere close to 10,500 AZ voters, of ANY voting persuasion, still in line 2 1/2 hours after the polls closed. Saying you "heard stories" doesn't cut it.

>>No one can prove or disprove it.

Lol. No one can prove or disprove whether Donald Trump was replaced at birth with a space-alien. Thus, we must entertain the notion that he is indeed a space-alien (which would make him ineligible to run for president). Right? That's your logic.

I get that fantasies are fun, but the one you're entertaining isn't supported by facts. Bring some facts, not just your feelings.

>>Moreover other state voters may be influenced by this practice.

This practice of calling a race, after the polls are closed, and only after there is no remaining pathway to victory for the trailing candidate? Tragic!

>>When the states say all votes are in (closed), the news weenies can sell their wares.

Or the news weenies can call races when the trailing candidate no longer has a pathway to victory, like they've been doing with strong success since before I was born, with very little controversy, right up until the point when the orange man cried, and his supporters' feelings were hurt.

And again, you're misusing the word "closed" in how it relates to elections polls.

>>Stirewalt is not alone

Correct. Every credible election team, over decades, has done what he did. He and Bill Sammon, however, are the only individuals I've ever heard of who were actually fired for making the correct call, with the numbers backing their call.

>>if he worked for CBS that night, Leslie Stahl would have kissed his rear end, and he would still be working there.

Who cares about what Leslie Stahl would do? Fox fired Stirewalt for performing his job extremely well. Why? Because the truth he told hurt MAGA-world's feelings. That's beyond pathetic.

Expand full comment
Thomas P.'s avatar

Interesting - I have to speak like a Philadelphia lawyer here, is it closed doors or closed as in all votes are in. Stick to the topic and stop obfuscating the main mode here. The news organs need to shut up during the voting event. If there is vote activity going on, pathways are irrelevant.

Expand full comment
John A. Daly's avatar

Thomas, all I'm asking is that if you throw out outlandish claims, you support those claims with facts rather than just your feelings. It makes for more productive conversations.

Expand full comment
Thomas P.'s avatar

Not a claim. Just news reports of people in line waiting to vote- after the doors close. With Az, thereтАЩs been a pattern of long lines since 2012 and thereafter. And so, I am exhausted with this. Happy Easter.

Expand full comment